Written on the back of the menu

How to play lateral thinking puzzles

What a lateral thinking puzzle is, the rules at this diner, and tips for asking good questions. One story and four answers: that is all there is to it, but knowing these might bring the rankings a little closer.

What is a lateral thinking puzzle?

A lateral thinking puzzle (also called a situation puzzle or a yes-or-no riddle) gives you a short, strange story, and you work out why it happened by asking only questions that can be answered "yes" or "no". The trick is to drop your assumptions and look at the story from another side.

In Japan the game is known as "Umigame no Soup" (sea turtle soup), after its most famous puzzle: a man orders sea turtle soup at a seaside restaurant, takes one taste, and later takes his own life. Why? That puzzle became so well known that the whole game took its name.

All it needs is someone to set the puzzle and someone to ask, so it has been played everywhere from gatherings of friends to online message boards. At this diner, an AI master sets the puzzles, so you can play alone, any time. Apart from the practice bowl, "The first bowl", every bowl on the menu was written for this diner.

The master's answers

The master answers each question with one of these. Only "Not a question" leaves your count alone.

Yes
True, measured against the truth.
No
False, measured against the truth.
Partly
Only partly true, or it depends.
Irrelevant
Has nothing to do with the truth, or the story leaves it undecided.
Not a question
Can't be answered with yes or no. It doesn't count as a question.

How questions are counted

The rankings go by fewest questions. The diner (the server) does all the counting.

What you doQuestions
Ask a question+1 (0 for "Not a question")
Ask for a whisper+3 (up to 2 per bowl)
Tell the truth and miss, or come close+1
Tell the truth and get it right0

The 30-question cap and the final chance

You have up to 30 questions per bowl. Once you reach 30, you can no longer ask or ask for a whisper.

After that, one last chance to tell the truth remains. Miss it and the bowl ends as "failed", and the truth is revealed. You can't ask for a whisper that would take you past 30.

Whispers (hints)

If you're stuck, ask the master for a whisper. What kind you get depends on how far along you are.

  • A distant whisper

    When you have few clues yet. It quietly points in a direction worth looking. It never states a fact.

  • A question-log whisper

    When you're partway there. It points at one of your own earlier questions and nudges you to dig there. No new information.

  • That's enough

    When every clue the truth needs is open. The master only tells you the clues are all there. This costs no questions and doesn't use up a whisper.

Facts uncovered and the order slip

Every bowl has a few "facts" that make up the truth. When a question touches one, it is written on the order slip. The slip shows how far along you are, and it is also what your truth has to cover. If your truth comes close, the facts you did cover open on the slip.

How a bowl ends

  • Solved: your truth was judged correct.
  • Gave up: you chose to give up and hear the truth.
  • Failed: your final truth after reaching 30 questions missed.

However it ends, the whole truth and every fact are revealed, and the master adds a closing word.

Tips for good questions

When the fewest questions win, how you ask makes the difference. These work for any bowl.

  1. 1Split wide, then narrow

    Instead of guessing details straight away, start with questions whose answer cuts the possibilities in half, like "Are there only two people in the story?" or "Did it happen indoors?".

  2. 2Doubt every word of the story

    Each word in the story was chosen on purpose. Is "the man" really a grown man? Who exactly "died"? Is "the house" an ordinary house? The words you read without a second thought are the ones worth checking.

  3. 3Check the when, where and who

    When you are stuck, ask when it happened, where, and who the people really are (their job, their role, even whether they are human). Change one assumption and the whole story can look different.

  4. 4"Irrelevant" is a clue too

    "Irrelevant" is not a miss: it tells you to drop that direction. "Partly" is a sign to split your question into the part that was right and the part that was not.

  5. 5Ask one thing at a time

    Mixing two things, like "Did the man cry and go home?", blurs the answer. Asking them separately usually costs fewer questions in the end.

  6. 6Reread the slip and your log

    Read the facts you have opened next to the answers so far, and the gaps you have not asked about yet start to show. When you think the key points are covered, tell the truth.

Want to set a puzzle for friends or family? Try the puzzles with answers, truths included.

The rankings

  • Only people who solve tonight's bowl on the same night (before midnight JST) are ranked. A bowl solved after midnight doesn't count.
  • Fewest questions first. On a tie, the shorter time; then whoever solved it first.
  • Time runs from your order to your solve, including any time you spent away from the screen.
  • You get one try at tonight's bowl per night. If you close the screen, you can pick up where you left off.
  • The rankings are shared between the Japanese and English versions. Names appear as public names.
  • Which master you choose has no effect on the rankings.

Reviews and spoilers

  • Only people who finished a bowl (solved, gave up or failed) can review it. One review per bowl, which you can edit later.
  • If your comment touches the truth, mark it "contains spoilers". It is folded away for anyone who hasn't finished that bowl.
  • Reviews of tonight's bowl stay hidden from everyone until the next midnight.

FAQ

Do I need to log in?
Not to read. To order (play), log in with your AI TRPG account.
The master's answers seem to contradict each other.
The AI master gets things wrong sometimes. Please tell us about an answer that seems off, as described in "Report a strange answer" below.
What happens if I stop partway?
Open the same bowl and you continue where you left off, even from another device. Tonight's bowl, though, won't be ranked if you finish it after midnight.
Can I ask two things at once?
Only one thing per question. Two at once tends to get "Partly" or "Not a question", so ask them separately.
How detailed does my truth need to be?
Covering the key facts of the story is enough. Exact wording doesn't matter. Write what happened in your own words.
Can I play in Japanese?
Yes. Switch the site language to Japanese and the story and the master's answers will be in Japanese. Tonight's bowl and the rankings are shared between both languages.

Report a strange answer

If the master gave an answer that contradicts the truth, or said something it shouldn't have, please let us know.

In the Question log on the game screen, every answer has a small flag button at its right end. Press the flag on the answer that bothered you, add a word on what seemed wrong if you like, and press "Send". The question and the answer go to the diner's admins, who use reports to fix that bowl's clarifications.

Reporting doesn't change your question count or your place in the rankings.